Stoughton residents are pressing town officials for answers after Police Chief Donna McNamara was removed from duty. A power struggle between the town manager and the Select Board has sparked widespread community unrest.

Key Takeaways

  • Donna McNamara removed from police chief duties
  • Residents demand transparency from town officials
  • Vote postponed due to absent Select Board members

Frustration is mounting in Stoughton as residents seek answers about who is currently running the police department and why Police Chief Donna McNamara was removed from her duties. Dozens of residents packed a Select Board meeting Thursday night, urging town leaders to keep McNamara in charge.

Instead of addressing the issue in open session, the Select Board immediately went into executive session with legal counsel. When asked who is currently leading the department, Select Board member Scott Carrara told Boston 25 News that McNamara remains the chief of police, but someone is filling in. Earlier this week, Town Manager Tom Calter announced that McNamara was off the job and that an acting chief had been appointed.

McNamara’s attorney sent a letter to town officials questioning whether she can be removed without a Select Board vote. Carrara explained that the town manager controls departmental operations but does not impose punishments, suggesting a vote may be required for a formal discharge. Two board members were absent, so no vote could be taken Thursday night.

Historical Background

The Stoughton Police Department has a long history of internal challenges, highlighted by the Sandra Birchmore case that exposed serious departmental concerns. McNamara’s efforts to reopen that case earned her praise from many residents, making her removal a particularly sensitive issue.

Why This Matters

BozokMedia analysis shows that the lack of transparency in leadership changes erodes public trust and can lead to heightened civic unrest, especially in municipalities with a history of police scrutiny.

"Removing a police chief without a transparent process undermines public confidence," said a public administration expert.
Did You Know?: Stoughton’s police force dates back to the 1800s and has undergone several major reforms over the decades.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is Donna McNamara’s current status?
A: She has been placed on administrative leave while an acting chief assumes her duties.

Q: When will the Select Board vote on the chief’s position?
A: No date has been set yet; the vote was delayed due to absent members.