Matthew Aaron VanDyke, detained since April, alleges a 14‑kg weight loss due to Tihar’s excessively oily, spicy fare. He has petitioned the court to prepare his own meals, requesting pasta, fish and other protein‑rich foods for health reasons.
Matthew Aaron VanDyke, an American citizen currently held in Tihar Jail on a National Investigation Agency (NIA) terror‑training case, has claimed that the prison’s standard diet is causing severe health deterioration. Since May 6, VanDyke says he has effectively been on a hunger strike because the meals are “excessively oily, spicy and fried.” He reports a loss of roughly 14 kilograms (about 30 pounds), weakened immunity, reduced stamina and visual problems attributed to malnutrition.
Legal Petition and Court Proceedings
In a petition filed before Additional Sessions Judge Prashant Sharma at Patiala House Court, VanDyke asked for permission to cook his own food. The request lists staples such as pasta, rice, lentils, vegetables and dairy alternatives, alongside protein sources like chicken, fish and red meat. He also seeks an induction stove and basic kitchen utensils, offering to bear all associated costs. The court directed Tihar officials to respond, with the next hearing slated for July 21.
Foreign Nationals and the NIA Investigation
VanDyke is one of six foreign nationals—five Ukrainians and himself—held in connection with an alleged international network that provided weapons, drone training and electronic‑jamming equipment to insurgent groups along the India‑Myanmar border. The NIA alleges the group entered India on tourist visas, traveled across Delhi, Lucknow and Kolkata, and then crossed illegally into Myanmar. On July 3, the Patiala House Court extended their judicial custody by 29 days, setting the next deadline for August 1.
Prison Food Standards and International Norms
India’s prison food policies have long been criticized for lacking nutritional balance, especially for foreign detainees who may have specific dietary needs. International human‑rights guidelines stipulate that inmates must receive meals that meet basic nutritional requirements and do not jeopardize health. Overly oily, heavily spiced fare can lead to hypertension, digestive disorders, and long‑term health risks—concerns echoed in VanDyke’s medical complaints.
Potential Implications
If the court grants VanDyke’s request, it could set a precedent for allowing self‑cooked meals in Indian prisons, prompting reforms that accommodate health‑related dietary adjustments. Conversely, the case remains entangled with the broader NIA investigation, highlighting the delicate balance between national security imperatives and the humane treatment of detainees. The outcome may influence how India handles foreign nationals accused of terrorism‑related offenses while adhering to international legal standards.