The Allahabad High Court has taken serious exception to allegations that Divisional Commissioner Durga Shakti Nagpal tried to sway a civil judge. The judge reported repeated calls during leave, raising concerns over judicial independence.

  • The judge received multiple calls from Durga Shakti Nagpal during leave
  • High Court deemed the pressure a threat to judicial independence
  • Civil society demands an independent probe

Background

Gonda civil judge complained that on July 15, while on leave, she received repeated calls from a number linked to the Devipatan Division Commissioner’s office, where IAS officer Durga Shakti Nagpal serves. Nagpal allegedly wanted to discuss a long‑pending land dispute and queried the judge about the duration of her leave.

High Court’s Reaction

The Allahabad High Court’s Lucknow Bench treated the allegation seriously, stating that such pressure "strikes at the independence of the judiciary and obstructs the administration of justice." Justice Syed Qamar Hasan Rizvi ordered that the matter not be dismissed and be referred to the bench handling criminal contempt.

Read Also:Vance Warns H‑1B Visa Should Protect American Jobs, Not Foreign Frauds

Judge’s Statement

The judge clarified that she never intended to discuss the merits of the case; she merely wanted to know when hearings would resume. She described the tone of the calls as "interference."

Civil Society’s Demands

Activist Amitabh Thakur wrote to the Chief Secretary demanding Nagpal’s transfer and an independent inquiry. He also called for clear protocols governing officials’ contact with judicial officers on pending matters.

Why This Matters

BozokMedia analysis shows that when senior bureaucrats directly interfere with judicial processes, it undermines the core principle of judicial independence and erodes public confidence in democratic institutions.

"Any encroachment on judicial independence weakens the very foundation of democracy," says constitutional law expert Dr. Anita Singh.
Did You Know?: The Indian Constitution explicitly separates the judiciary from the executive to safeguard impartial justice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Has any disciplinary action been taken against Durga Shakti Nagpal?

A: No official action has been recorded yet; the matter is pending before the High Court.

Q: What measures can prevent such incidents in the future?

A: Establishing clear contact protocols, independent oversight, and regular training for officials are essential steps.